I can't help on what to use, but I had a stone hit on my 2018 Sport Touring Hatchback fog light, left side also, but the light still worked. A heads up. I found out to replace the bulb with anything, the front bumper had to be removed. No easy access. I had a body shop do it, as at the same time I replaced my wimpy meep, meep horn, with a much better louder one. They did both jobs at the same time, & as I recall, didn't charge me that bad a price.