Amuses me how someone might select their real life car based on a track record. What, do I need to race to my office and get there 3.6 seconds earlier?
It's kid's stuff to make such a decision based on numbers, including having "only" 485 hp when the other car has 495. Either has several times enough to get you arrested or killed.
Buy your car based on how much fun and joy it brings to you when you do real world driving. Both cars are plenty quick and impressive.
2015 Civic Si
1974, 2005, 2011 Lotus cars
2015 Toyota Tundra TRD PRO (it's orange too)