I ended up going with the Phantom Mat! Purchased through Costco, these ended up being just about $220 shipped to my door for the front and rear mats. At the time they did not make the trunk liner so I will be purchasing that at a later date. These are essentially Tuxmats, just a different name stamp.
They cover every bit of carpet in the car and I like how they don't have a plastic or rubber look. For winter driving I have been tracking lots of salt onto the mats, however, all it takes is a wipe down with a microfiber cloth and its back to normal! Highly recommend and they do not interfere with the clutch either.
I bought the Honda All-weather mats when I purchased the car. Here in the Pacific Northwest, it is wet with pine needles and leaves. After 3-years the Honda mats started to curl at the edges and the coverage under the 3 pedals was pretty minimal from the start - Honda is probably worried about a liability issue with the rubber getting caught in the pedals. Went with the Weathertech Floorliner HP mats. Much better coverage and is easier to keep clean. Should have bought the WT mats to begin with. Go with the best!